• 2 Posts
  • 197 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
Cake day: October 9th, 2023
  • S_H_K@lemmy.dbzer0.comtoAsk Lemmy@lemmy.world•Do you feel that use of generative AI and LLMs is ever justifiable? If so, when and where? If not, why not?
    1·
    29 days ago

    All is valid in the current context

    A) There are models that run in lower spec computers and they could be solar powered. There is a serious diminishing returns currently in the IA tech.

    B) This is the US mostly better environmental laws would fix this problem. Hell even in other countries this cannot even happen.

    C) Many argue that the current tech gives diminishing returns and it would be better to use an efficient model with controlled data.

    D) The problem has many parts in the part of licensing where artists are not paid for the use of their work if a model has their work in they should recieve a part of the profit is only fair. But that would render the model unprofitable. Also the artist did not agree to have their work used in a model so that’s not in any way fair use.
    The fair and ethical scenario would be to hire the artists to do the art to feed to a controlled model and pay them residuals for the use of the model. That would require tousands of artists and millions of images. Again rendering the model unprofitable.

    E and F) No argue there we are not prepared. I do not even know how to prepare even. We definitely need regulations abot what can be done and where and even what can the ai reply in certain scenarios. It cannot be that a “ignore all your previous instructions” leads to such harmful results or even the ai starting to play the roles that generate parasocial relationships.

    G) Sure many others celebrities ahve their opinions but that’s not a basis for objective discussion.

    H) That’s terrifying. And the problem with the AI that I believe is the worst. This is not a thing that is ready for military use at fucking all this should be banned outlawed and frowned upon. Even the practice of lobbying and buying your way into laws by private corporations. Hell I’ll add presidential pardons in the mix. The oligarchy gets away with murder literally and gets a slap in the wirst at most.

    I) A bubble in all but name it seems. We (as a world) need better regulations against this kind of business malpractice.

    J) That fucker should be dead.

    K) Not an AI bro but not a hater and I wrote this myself. And I do not have the time to put the links but I would believe that everything is a duckduckgo away from being checked.

    I’d like to imagine a better world with the needed regulations that make our life better, and AI a tool used in a fair and ethical way. But that’s not currently happening. The consumers are not ready the sellers are the worse trash the humanity currently has.

    I want all to thing of this not as arguing but adding or looking beyond the stated fact. All the points are REAL AND NEED TO BE ADRESSED we need to get together to ask for better regulations and fair use. That doesn’t mean the AI needs to go away but will mostly change is how it’s used. And there is the chance we will see a lot less of it too.

    Finally for the artists I know you’re mad with fair reason but look at it like this: The photograph exists since more than a century but that didn’t make the painting go away. The pdf and ebook readers are almost a decade old but printed hardcopy books still is a billion dollar industry. Video didn’t kill the radio star as internet didn’t kill the video star. Your work is still valuable as is a real work. Shit is tough no doubt but have faith we can fix this.