I do agree in the end it’s arbitrary, and you’re right there are 2 extremes in strategy, purely analytical and purely reflexive, plus everything in between.
Admittedly without having played this game specifically using both strategies this is purely speculation. But from my experience playing similar games, exactly to your point of the two strategies, if time and moves are weighed equally, I feel like a player using the analytics strategy would end up with a much higher score than a reflex based player at the “same” skill level (however “skill” levels would be pretty hard to quantify and compare by the two strategies).
Hope that makes sense :)
As someone who skates and hasn’t rollerbladed since 2010 and does not perform on either, I’m going to say no. If you’re asking because you’re going to see a performance, it’ll probably be just as enjoyable. But if you’re asking because someone you know is bragging about rollerblading, they are full of shit.